哥们，移民到国外个一二十年，亲身体验一下，走走看看，别靠知乎百度之类的看西方。
芝加哥交响乐团可以么？不知道能不能入高品位水木鉴赏家的眼，还不是照样出演出事故。

乐器演奏就是个重复再重复的反复磨，交响乐涉及到协作，纪律性协调力占主导，西方交响乐传到东方，反而更适合中日韩这种组织性纪律性强且平均智商高的黄皮亚洲种族，最重要的是我们特别刻苦努力，所以我们才可以用很短的时间把演奏水平发展好，但是毕竟东西是人家发明的，人家有历史盛名，我们黄皮交响乐团徒有水平，没有名气是必然。

摘抄一个油管视频下几条有意思的评论，日本一所国立小学的管乐团的视频（打脸添菊私立）
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAfy5e6uXs8

————I've been to Japan and visited a few school bands. The only reason they are so good its because their band schedule/practice are everyday after school and that includes Saturdays and Sundays except for public holidays with minimum practice duration of at least 4 hours/day. Students who join the band in their school must be ready to commit to the band practice schedule or face disciplinary action, either expulsion from band or expulsion from school. It boils down to "Practice makes perfect"

————you say "only" as if that isn't a valid enough reason. That's the reason why all bands get good; practice. Though i do agree, Japanese bands are probably much better than bands back in 'murica because of the strict practice requirements. I could never practice 4 hours a day.. then again this is elementary meaning less homework

————u are right. im in japanese school band, which reqires us to practice on Weekends, afterschool, and holidays. but it is very fun, and its not only us, also the other clubs in  school like soccer club, baseball, badketball, all other clubs have to practice on Weekends and afterschool, holidays
but we can talk, play, when taking break so its soooo fun

————My marching director: "I want you to be the best band in Canada" Some kid: "Why not in the world?" Marching director "We don't live in Asia."

【 在 FLYBBS 的大作中提到: 】
: 知乎上有个问题，国内一流乐团和国际著名乐团的差距在哪里？
: 所有专业人士的回答，都是差一个档次。
: 这个比较直白
: ...................
--
FROM 73.69.254.*