翻了当时的调试信息给AI看,AI说指令应该被拒绝了
所以为啥现在硬盘的行为出现了变化Orz..
---
以下是eb70dab98d0版本运行时输出的调试信息,请解读这里面的ATA指令的输出结果
```root@pve:~/scripts# ./hdstat-musl -v /dev/sda
Trying SG_IO interface...
CDB for ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1 (SG_IO): 85 0e 0e 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 a0 e5 00
ATA_TF for ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1: command=0xe5, dev=0xa0, nsect=0x00, feat=0x00
SG_IO (ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1) command sent. SCSI status: 0x2, host status: 0x0, driver status: 0x8. Raw status from sb[13]: 0x00
SG_IO: sb[]: 70 00 05 00 00 00 00 12 00 00 00 00 24 00 00 c0 00 01 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00
Trying SG_IO (ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE2)...
CDB for ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE2 (SG_IO): 85 0e 0e 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 a0 98 00
ATA_TF for ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE2: command=0x98, dev=0xa0, nsect=0x00, feat=0x00
SG_IO (ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE2) command sent. SCSI status: 0x2, host status: 0x0, driver status: 0x8. Raw status from sb[13]: 0x00
Trying traditional HDIO_DRIVE_CMD IOCTL...
Args for ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1 (HDIO_DRIVE_CMD): e5 00 00 00
HDIO_DRIVE_CMD (ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1) successful. Raw status: 0xff
active/idle
root@pve:~/scripts#
```
---
根据提供的调试输出,我来解读其中ATA指令的输出结果:
1. **SG_IO接口尝试 - ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1 (0xE5)**
- CDB: `85 0e 0e 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 a0 e5 00`
- ATA任务文件: `command=0xe5, dev=0xa0, nsect=0x00, feat=0x00`
- 结果:
- SCSI状态: `0x2` (CHECK CONDITION)
- 驱动状态: `0x8` (DRIVER_SENSE)
- Sense Buffer: `70 00 05 00 00 00 00 12 00 00 00 00 24 00 00 c0 00 01 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00`
**解读**:
- CDB中的`cdb[1]=0x0e`和`cdb[2]=0x0e`与之前分析一致
- Sense Buffer分析:
- Byte 0: `0x70` - 表示固定格式的sense数据
- Byte 2: `0x05` - SENSE KEY = 0x5 (ILLEGAL REQUEST)
- Byte 12: `0x24` - ASC (Additional Sense Code) = 0x24 (INVALID FIELD IN CDB)
- Byte 13: `0x00` - ASCQ = 0x00
- **结论**: SCSI层拒绝了CDB命令,原因是"CDB中的无效字段"(INVALID FIELD IN CDB),这与之前分析的`cdb[1]=0x0e`值不符合SG_IO协议定义一致。
2. **SG_IO接口尝试 - ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE2 (0x98)**
- CDB: `85 0e 0e 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 a0 98 00`
- ATA任务文件: `command=0x98, dev=0xa0, nsect=0x00, feat=0x00`
- 结果:
- SCSI状态: `0x2` (CHECK CONDITION)
- 驱动状态: `0x8` (DRIVER_SENSE)
- 程序没有输出完整的Sense Buffer
**解读**:
- 相同的CDB结构问题导致SCSI层再次拒绝命令
- 虽然没有完整Sense Buffer,但错误状态与第一个命令相同,可以推断也是"INVALID FIELD IN CDB"错误
3. **传统IDE IOCTL (HDIO_DRIVE_CMD)**
- 参数: `e5 00 00 00`
- 结果: `Raw status: 0xff`
- 最终输出: `active/idle`
**解读**:
- `HDIO_DRIVE_CMD`成功发送了ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1命令
- 返回状态`0xff`对应`get_power_mode_string()`中的"active/idle"状态
- 这表明硬盘处于活动或空闲状态
**总体分析**:
1. SG_IO路径由于CDB格式问题完全失败,SCSI层拒绝了两个CHECKPOWERMODE命令
2. 传统IDE IOCTL路径成功执行了ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1命令
3. 硬盘返回状态`0xff`,表示处于"active/idle"状态
4. 程序最终正确输出了硬盘的电源状态,但这完全依赖于传统IDE IOCTL路径
根据调试输出中的ATA指令结果分析:
1. **SG_IO路径执行结果**:
- 尝试发送`ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1`(0xE5)命令失败:
- SCSI状态:0x2 (CHECK CONDITION)
- Sense Buffer:70 00 05 00 00 00 00 12 00 00 00 00 24 00 00 c0 00 01 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00
- 错误解析:ASC 0x24 (INVALID FIELD IN CDB) - 表明CDB格式无效
- 尝试发送`ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE2`(0x98)命令同样失败,错误原因相同
2. **传统IDE IOCTL路径执行结果**:
- 成功发送`ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1`(0xE5)命令
- 返回状态:0xff
- 对应电源状态:"active/idle"(活动/空闲状态)
3. **总体结论**:
- SG_IO路径因CDB格式问题(`cdb[1]=0x0e`值无效)未能向硬盘发出有效指令
- 传统IDE IOCTL路径成功向硬盘发出`ATA_OP_CHECKPOWERMODE1`指令
- 硬盘响应状态0xff,表示处于活动或空闲状态
- 程序最终输出"active/idle"是基于传统IOCTL路径的成功执行
--
FROM 182.108.9.*