之前没有发过

第一次投稿，之前投QJE，被拒了，
说是
I have read your paper with much interest. The paper is well written and I have found many aspects of your analysis novel and insightful. I have concluded, however, that the contribution of the paper is not suitable for publication in the QJE.

然后改了改，投给了RES，也被拒了
说是
I enjoyed reading your paper. Although I think it is interesting, I am afraid I believe that the extent of the contribution is a better fit for a more specialized journal.

哎，太难了。
这些杂志的文章，我也经常看，说实话，没有一篇文章有啥贡献的。 全是讨论鸡毛蒜皮的事情，得出鸡毛蒜皮的结论。我给他投篇真正的大文章，他们还认为，研究的太小众。

不多 ，对比下，就会发现，QJE的主编，显然比RES的编辑，更专业。QJE主编看到了文章的价值，他拒绝的原因，是文章重点是微观经济学，不太适合QJE的风格。RES的拒信，就太业余了。






【 在 Vigee 的大作中提到: 】
: lz之前发过的最牛期刊是哪本？
--
FROM 221.216.0.*