- 主题:陶说张的论文有些细节错误,可能需要较长时间弥补,不幸被我言
--来自微微水木3.5.12
--
FROM 27.29.205.*
为啥不能是陶错了呢,Yau也说佩雷尔曼。。。
【 在 spioner007 的大作中提到: 】
: --来自微微水木3.5.12
--
FROM 223.94.53.*
直觉是70岁的老人出错的概率大啊
【 在 Milutinovic 的大作中提到: 】
: 为啥不能是陶错了呢,Yau也说佩雷尔曼。。。
--
FROM 183.9.87.*
陶指出来具体错误的地方了,可看他博客
【 在 Milutinovic 的大作中提到: 】
: 为啥不能是陶错了呢,Yau也说佩雷尔曼。。。
:
: 【 在 spioner007 的大作中提到: 】
: ...................
--来自微微水木3.5.12
--
FROM 27.29.205.*
哪里说较长时间?
take some time, 翻译成花一些时间
Tao 也没说有错误, 只是说少了一些步骤的说明
附原文
Tao:
At this point the essential correctness of the manuscript is unconfirmed. There are a number of misprints and technical issues in the paper (mostly centering around Sections 11 and 12) that are hindering the verification process and which I have forwarded to Yitang in order to request clarification. For instance, there are references to non-existent equations (8.25) and (8.26) on pages 64, 65, 67, (10.) on page 67, (15.) on pages 98 and 99, “(4) and (4)” on pages 67 and 69, “(5) and (5)” on page 63, and (A) and (14) on page 109; there also appears to be a reference missing completely just before Lemma 12.3 on page 70 (as well as just before the aforementioned reference to (A) on page 109), and the function \varkappa_4 that appears from page 96 onwards is never defined in the paper. As a consequence, several steps in the manuscript currently have no valid justification provided. It is possible that these (as well as some more serious issues) can be corrected, but it will likely take some time before the process resolves (in particular, I would not want to pressure Yitang to upload a hastily edited revision of the manuscript instead of a carefully proofread one), and so patience is advised.
【 在 spioner007 的大作中提到: 】
--
修改:abettor FROM 211.145.70.*
FROM 211.145.70.*
【 在 abettor 的大作中提到: 】
: 哪里说较长时间?
: take some time, 翻译成花一些时间
: Tao 也没说有错误, 只是说少了一些步骤的说明
: ...................
有点好奇TAO是指缺失的那些步骤他短时间内也没法推导出来,还是TAO更多的是从论文的严谨性方面提醒张。
--
修改:hongdiao FROM 222.126.214.*
FROM 222.126.214.*
张益唐得提供那些东西吧。还有没定义的函数。
【 在 hongdiao 的大作中提到: 】
:
: 有点好奇TAO是指缺失的那些步骤他短时间内也没法推导出来,还是TAO更多的是从论文的严谨性方面提醒张。
--
FROM 114.241.227.*
这俩都是解析数论为主的哈
【 在 spioner007 的大作中提到: 】
: 陶指出来具体错误的地方了,可看他博客
--
FROM 106.121.188.*
感觉解析数论就喜欢用筛,各种筛,像是淘金的
【 在 spioner007 的大作中提到: 】
--
FROM 106.121.188.*
陶哲轩最近点评了张益唐的论文,老张现在有压力了 - 磁悬浮青蛙呱呱呱的文章 - 知乎
https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/584071371
错误在此
我觉得terrytao只是委婉的说法吧,几个公式编号的错误对他读懂论文应该不会有大的影
响。
【 在 hongdiao 的大作中提到: 】
: 有点好奇TAO是指缺失的那些步骤他短时间内也没法推导出来,还是TAO更多的是从论文
: 的严谨性方面提醒张。
--
FROM 119.139.197.*