这种就属于编辑自己没主意，编辑既然发给你让二修，就是他不想让你改投他刊
但是呢，编辑自己也没主意或者没精力去看论文应该在哪些点上继续提高，所以就把个模糊意见发给你，让你自己琢磨着修改，大概这么个意思吧
【 在 shong 的大作中提到: 】
: 论文已经修回一次了（当时是两个外审专家），现在又给出了修订稿的审稿结果，只有一个审稿专家了，结果如下：
: Reviewer #1: The authors have performed an extensive revision of their submission to the journal, accompanied by an also extensive response to the reviewers. However, as it stands, the revision per se - in terms of the improvements recommended by the reviewers in their initial review of the ms in question - is not adequate in terms of either depth, or critical detail, to grant publication to the journal.
: The submission could be considered for publication to a "sister" journal, if the Editors of both the journal and the sister-journal agree.
: ...................
--
FROM 111.192.241.*